If by "judge" you mean Montgomery , you are correct. He is a coach that has set up a "system", no matter the skills of his QBs or their ability to run it. That is why the "system" is now failing and why I projected that Wells would never be a 4 year starter when he started as a Frosh-- lacks necessary skills for the system and has no running ability to add another dimension.
Recruitng Hosick reveals a tacit admission that they DON'T have a QB for the system and they are banking on Hosick fitting in as a crude replacement . They have the early games to experiment with the QBs and give some playing time to the Top 2 or 3, hoping that the gamble will pay off. Wells, only because he was the starter will hold sway unless he is beaten out badly in camp. If he is, then the early games may simply be on the job training, especially against the weenie teams and they try to find the skills that can be shoehorned into the "system". FRankly, they have done a poor job of recruiting if they are trying to fit someone into the "system" instead of building a different system around the players here.
Wells -- limited arm, lacks accuracy, no run skills and puts it up for grabs too often. His first year was a nightmare but opposing players dropped an astonishing numbers of easy INTs. Not so his Soph. year and teams read him as wilting under pressure. They are correct.
Davis -- has much better run skills but they have limited his passing, so that is tough to read.
Garry -- at best , a D-II QB. Senior and offers no future.
Mays -- they won't try to develop him . Limited skills and again looks like a D-II player. Not good enough to beat any QB on the team . Frosh with a limited upside
Hosick -- depending on WHAT they run, he has some passing AND running skills. However, he is limited and to get better production out of the system they employ, Montgomery must tailor the O to fit his skill set. I suspect they will fast track him. They are betting the farm on him. However, there are reasons he was not grabbed by D-I schools. Translation -- limited abilities.
This however puts them with 1 senior and 3 juniors at QB with a Frosh who isn't going to play here. The next two recruit classes will have them behind the 8 ball -- a Frosh is usually no immediate help and another Juco may be the answer while they look for a Frosh project that might play with some seasoning of a few years . With two bad recruit classes so far, it will be tough to turn it around.