Is Calhoun deserving of job offers from better basketball schools or a pay increase from YSU to keep him here?
Calhoun's record in six years at YSU is 96 wins and 95 losses. The real record is 82 - 95 when you deduct games played against D2 and D3 competition, who we had no business scheduling in the first place. Granted he did not inherit a thriving program. On the other hand, it took him six years to bring the Penguins to the middle of the pack of D1 basketball.
The 2022 - 2023 record, 24 - 9, adds insight. It was against a strength of schedule rating of Sagarin 308. There are 363 Division 1 basketball teams. The highest rated opponent we played was Notre Dame, at 120. Our best victory was against Northern Kentucky, at 158. Ten of the wins were against cupcakes, bottom dwellers and D3.
Westminster (D3)
Grace Christian (D3)
UC San Diego 277 (8 - 20)
Southern 294 (13 - 17)
Tennessee - Martin 302 (15 - 14)
Central Michigan 326 (9 - 21)
IUPUI (twice) 353 (3 - 27)
Green Bay (twice) 362 (3 - 29)
Canisius (9 - 20) and Western Illinois (13 - 14) were not much better. The Horizon League games were what they had to be. The others were not.
In the biggest game of the year, he was outcoached by Northern Kentucky's Darrin Horn, unprepared for their game strategy, and slow to react. We all saw it.
Calhoun has more to prove at YSU before another team throws money at him.