First of all, I'm not sure why Tressel would want the stress and aggravation that comes with being President of a University. He seems very comfortable and at peace in his current position at Akron. I really do not see him leaving Akron unless it would be for a Head Coaching job in the NFL.
As for Tressel as President at Akron, just do not see that happening. I understand that being able to raise money and do all of the PR things are a big part of being a University President. But, I think it is also important to have a person with a strong academic background in higher education. The job at Akron is a very good fit for Tressel, because he gets to interact with students, faculty and staff, teaches and he also helps with fundraising and increasing the profile of the University.
I think it would be great to have him in the administration at YSU, but not as President. It really does not say much about YSU if Jim Tressel is the best the school can do as it's President. Then again, in the Mahoning Valley, it seems as if the vast majority of Principals and Superintendents in the K-12 schools system are former coaches. So, not really a surprise that many in the area, even those who are "prominent" would be pushing for Tressel as President.